Best Underlay for LVT and Vinyl Flooring

LVT and Vinyl flooring are some of the most cost-effective and beneficial floors on the market. The only way to make them better? Add an underlay. But what is an underlay, and what’s the best underlay for LVT flooring? And what’s the best underlay for vinyl flooring? (Hint: They’re different in most cases because LVT flooring underlay and vinyl underlay are designed to enhance and protect fundamentally different – albeit similar – flooring types).

This article will review the types of underlay that bring out the best in vinyl sheet flooring and Luxury Vinyl Tile click flooring, and enhance its pros. Read on to find out more. 

Types of Underlay

The following are the types of underlay, along with their typical strengths and uses, though bear in mind specialised brand products may have additional features. 

Felt Underlay

Felt underlays have two main strong points: 

• Sound Absorption – Felt underlays offer good sound absorption, ensuring that impact noise is reduced and noise transmission between rooms is lowered, allowing for more peace and comfort in your home. Ideal for hard floors like vinyl and LVT flooring.
• Cost-effective – Felt underlays are made with low-cost materials, making them highly affordable for most homeowners – ideal when laying vinyl flooring and looking for an effective underlay that doesn’t increase the cost too much.

Felt does have a limiting negative though: 

• Moisture – Felt underlays have very low moisture resistance, meaning when set up in areas like bathrooms or kitchens, they will likely suffer damage quickly – not great considering LVT and vinyl flooring are popular choices in kitchens.

Foam Underlay

Foam underlays are a versatile option that boasts several pros: 

• Cushioning – Foam underlays offer various levels of cushioning due to their multiple thickness options, which is primarily where the soft feeling comes from. In bedrooms, living rooms, or other areas of comfort, foam underlays do well. Best paired with flooring that is otherwise lacking in comfort like vinyl or LVT flooring.
• Thermal Insulation – Foam’s material lends itself well to thermal resistance, which means it doesn’t allow heat to pass through the material. Making a would-be cold vinyl floor that much more comfortable.
• Vapour Barrier – Bear in mind that not all foam has vapour barriers. The ones that do tend to be thinner, and are often a top choice for basements that have concrete subfloors, as water can seep into the pores of concrete and maintain moisture. (If you need to protect against water rising up from a concrete subfloor, you may need a damp-proof membrane as additional support).

Foam is wildly popular due to its added benefits, with not many cons to think of. That being said: 

• Quality – When it comes to foam underlays, quality is everything. A low-quality foam underlay will compress and wear out much faster than other foam underlays. Whilst quality is a factor for all underlays, we feel it reflects most in low-quality foam. 

Crumb Rubber Underlay

Crumb rubber underlays boast two main strengths:

• Sound Reduction – Crumb rubber underlays are unmatched when it comes to acoustic insulation, due to its material makeup, it can very easily absorb and kill sound. Its sound absorption is so good that many homeowners consider it ideal for multi-story dwellings etc. 
• Durability – Crumb rubber has exceptional durability. It can withstand a huge amount of foot traffic as a result, and has a huge impact on the final look of your floor. Ideal considering LVT and vinyl flooring are also notoriously robust, making the whole set up even more durable.

Crumb rubber does have some drawbacks, however: 

• Uncomfortable – Crumb rubber is very dense, but not all that thick. This can be offset by putting it beneath a great floor. 

Cork Underlay

Cork is a natural material that has many benefits:

• Moisture Resistance – Cork’s natural material lends itself well to resisting moisture, mould, and mildew. This makes it perfect for putting in areas that are usually fairly wet, such as bathrooms, kitchens and basements. 
• Sound Resistance – Cork dampens sounds of both impact noise and airborne sound transmission making your home a quieter place. Important on those harder LVT, vinyl or even laminate flooring options.
• Thermal Insulation – Cork can help with thermal insulation, maintaining stable floor temperatures and stopping heat from escaping through the floor. 
• Eco-Friendly – Cork is harvested through sustainable sources – that of cork wood trees, and better yet, it doesn’t harm the trees. They are also biodegradable and non-toxic. 

Cork disadvantages are similar to the previous entry: 

• Less Soft – Cork isn’t a dense material, but at the same time, it doesn’t offer comfort. 
• Odour – Cork has a rubbery odour, although, over time, it dissipates. 

Combination Underlay 

These underlays are aptly named, promoting several underlay benefits into one underlay: 

• All-round performance – Combo underlays mix several benefits of other underlays into one. These include soundproofing, moisture protection, cushioning, sound/thermal insulation – etc. 
• Simplified Installation – Some people install multiple underlays for complex rooms with several needs, but a combination underlay cuts out the others. 

Whilst not necessarily a con, the following is something to keep in mind: 

• No specialisation – Combination underlays can be described as a jack of all trades, but a master of none. 

The Best Underlay for Vinyl Flooring (Sheet).

This may be a shock, but it isn’t considered necessary to have vinyl flooring underlay in most cases. This is because sheet vinyl flooring comes with a backing layer that provides cushioning and support. Adding an extra layer of cushioning underlay beneath vinyl flooring may give it a “bounce” rather than cushioning underfoot – a novelty that will get old fast.

If you were to add vinyl flooring underlay, there are most definitely applications that help, however: 

• Uneven Subfloor – Subfloor imperfections such as some dips and bumps will reflect in the sheet vinyl. As a result, it may be better to get a thin foam to provide a smooth surface at the start of your flooring project.
• Soundproofing – Sheet vinyl doesn’t have a lot of soundproofing properties. As a result, having a thin sheet of cork underlay increases acoustic insulation. 
• Moisture – In moisture-prone areas, such as basements and bathrooms, an underlay with a moisture barrier can create a barrier between the sheet vinyl and the moisture, protecting the longevity of the flooring.

The Best Underlay for LVT

Luxury Vinyl flooring is hard but very secure, comfortable and warm underfoot. Despite being made up of more layers and generally being of a much better quality than sheet vinyl in all areas except cost (but not value), it doesn’t have one thing sheet vinyl does – the backing layer. This means that LVT is a lot more compatible with underlays. In fact – LVT flooring NEEDS an appropriate underlay to make sure it lasts as long as possible and provides you with the comfort you’re looking for.

The first thing to point out is that SoundBarrier (an underlay available at QA specifically created for LVT flooring) is compatible with both Gluedown and Click LVT installations – a rarity with LVT underlays, meaning you really have a one stop shop when you work with QA for your LVT underlay. 

In truth, it’s better to go with underlay options specifically designed for LVT. Whilst we’ve taken the time to go over the different types of underlay, this was mainly so that you understand what each underlay offers. QA has a specific LVT specialised underlay that mimics many of the benefits of the underlays above, and we’d like to introduce you to it below. 

SoundBarrier LVT Underlay

The following is QA’s very own underlay designed for LVT. When looking for the best underlay for LVT, understanding this highly compatible flooring will help with all your acoustic solutions and it’s appropriate for both click and gluedown installations.

Conclusion

Overall, the right underlay for either LVT or Sheet Vinyl depends entirely on your needs. Whilst the options for Vinyl are fairly sparse and situational, it’s not entirely uncommon for LVT to have their own specialised underlay, such as SoundBarrier, which can further enhance LVTs range of benefits.